The East German Olympic Training System – Frank Shuman
(1977)
Strength & Health June-July 1977
With the Olympics starting in a couple weeks I figured it'll be fun to look back at some all-time bad takes on past Olympic performances. At least one photo in the feature was a Bruce Klemens heater that I didn't see him get credit for. Do yourself a favor and go check out his flickr account:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/bklemens/albums/72157669291356315/
Bruce is still showing up to US Nationals and taking photos.
The 1976 Olympics in Montreal were filled with many
surprises by the emergence of East Germany as an Olympic power might have been
the biggest surprise of all. And yet, it did not come as a surprise to anyone
following international competitions, for they knew that the East Germans had
developed an all-encompassing training system for their athletes in all sports.
This year, however, for the first time, some of the secrets
have been revealed to the West. The German Democratic Republic (East Germany)
invited a group of Western journalists to visit their sports facilities around
the country and to investigate, somewhat, their training programs.
Much of the information in this article is based on the
report of one of these journalists, Craig B. Whitney, to the New York Times.
Although the East Germans won more gold medals (40) than any
other country except the USSR, they are already laying the groundwork for their
assault on the XXII Olympiad in Moscow in 1980.
Their system which also produced 25 silver and 25 bronze
medals in Montreal is comprised of teams of doctors, coaches and athletes.
There are 21 sports clubs around the country and 19 specialized sports schools,
which arrange their curriculum hours to fit around the student-athletes’ needs.
The Sports and Gymnastics Club in East Berlin is one of the
largest in the country and it has over 600 athletes training there for three
and four hours a day under 32 professional coaches. The budget is over $500,000
and the training facilities include gyms for soccer, handball, basketball and
gymnastics. There are also special weightlifting rooms, boxing rings, an indoor
ice-skating rink, and swimming pools with diving boards made in Sparks, Nevada.
Since East Germany is a relatively small country (population
17 million), it can be assumed that the sports clubs and specialized schools
are within easy distance of all their athletes. This isn’t really true, of
course. The clubs and schools are open only to those athletes with promise.
Ulrike Richter, the 18-year old backstroke champion, for example, was
“discovered” by a “scout” when she was six years old and she was put in a
special boarding school in East Berlin even though her family live 100 miles away.
Unfortunately, this is the rule and not the exception. Most
of the East German athletes have been in serious and supervised training since
their early, formative years.
The United States can loo with envy upon the results of
other systems but there will surely be no one clamoring for us to emulate these
systems and “imprison” our young and potential champion athletes.
On the other hand, the East German athletes do not consider
themselves imprisoned. They seem genuinely concerned with strengthening the
international reputation of the German Democratic Republic and this is why the
long-isolated East German regime is willing to spend so much money on it.
In addition to the clubs and sports schools, the army is
another organization entrusted with turning out athletes. They are able to
offer outstanding facilities for training and their soldier-athletes are often
promoted in the ranks according to how they’ve progressed in competition.
The system itself, however, is built upon a foundation of
national sports. Physical education classes of two to three hours a week, for
example, are compulsory for every East German schoolchild, beginning with the
first grade. The coaches in these schools, then, act as “talent scouts” and
they appear to know what they’re looking for as most schools send five or six
students a year to the special sports schools. There is some room for dissent,
though, and a student who is picked for one of the sports schools can refuse to
attend.
As stated, however, attending these schools and belonging to
the clubs or the army is a privilege open only to superior athletes. Anyone who
has any ambition as far as the Olympics are concerned will join because there
are simply no other ways to attain the Olympic standards. There is no such
thing in East Germany as training on one’s own in neighborhood gyms.
How does the government pay for its programs and facilities?
We in the United States have seen all sorts of fundraising events but it is
doubtful if we would accept the East German way. They encourage workers to
spend an extra shift at the factory and then to donate those wages to the
sports programs. A sports official in Leipzig says “The majority do it
voluntarily, but of course those who don’t volunteer, go along with the others
anyway.”
And it takes a lot of extra shifts to pay for the East
German program and facilities. In addition to the half-million dollar budget in
East Berlin, the little town of Wunschendorf has a budget of at least $160,000
a year for its programs.
The East German Gymnastics and Sports Federation has 2.66
million members and there is an elite sports club in Zella-Mehlis specializing
in skiing, skating and wrestling. In Halle, in a modern building along the
Saale river, there is a sports medicine office (wink wink, cough cough)
specializing in swimming. In Leipzig, there is the German Sports Institute,
which has produced more than 7,000 trained coaches and athletes.
There is a special department of sports medicine at the
Institute with a staff of 85, and research there is believed to be the most
advanced in its field in the entire world. The Leipzig Research Center is
equipped with all sorts of complex medical equipment and swimmers train there
with masks on so that doctors can study their metabolic rates. Dr. Alois
Marder, who was graduated from the Institute and worked at the swimming club in
Halle with Kornelia Ender, fled to West Germany two years ago. He is the one
who provided the first information about the East German swim training.
According to him, the tests made on the swimmers involve
blood samples taken in the first, second, fifth and 10th minutes of
a workout, so that the buildup of lactic acid in the blood- and thus the level
of physical exhaustion – can be monitored at every stage.
This method is used to predict the maximum performance
attainable by an athlete. Dr. Marder said that he took a sample of blood from
Kornelia Ender’s earlobe in 1973 and he knew she could swim the 100-meter
freestyle in 56 seconds. That is exactly what she did last summer in Montreal!
Dr. Marder explained at the West German Sports Institute in Cologne, where he
is now trying to do the same kind of research, that the lactic acid level is
the key.
“Lactic acid builds up in the bloodstream as the muscles
work hard,” he said. “It builds up to a certain level and then exhaustion sets
in. If you measure the levels in a swimmer’s bloodstream at a constant speed
after one, two, five and 10 minutes, you can draw a line on a graph and predict
accurately how fast he can swim – and then train him to that level.”
Some athletes’ metabolism, he claims, make it impossible for
them to work their bodies as hard as Miss Ender could. The athletes who can
work as hard are the ones who care given such intensive training. And is it all
worthwhile? Well, maybe not by American standards. Living in a free enterprise
system, our athletes are pressed with the need of making a living. Such a thing
is not a factor in East Germany.
The athletes who do succeed make nowhere near the money and
get nowhere near the benefits our professional athletes receive but neither do
they go wanting. After her spectacular performance of winning one silver and
four gold medals in Montreal, Miss Ender received a government-sponsored
vacation trip to Cuba along with her fiancé, Roland Matthes, the backstroke
swimmer. They will also be assured of an apartment and maybe a new car without
the standard eight-year wait. Miss Ender will probably receive another
important benefit. She wants to study medicine – a coveted field in East
Germany – and her plans will probably not be disappointed, although no one else
contemplating a career in medicine can be so sure.
“I gave the state quite a lot with my four gold medals,”
said Miss Ender, “and now I’d like to make a contribution to society as a pediatrician,
perhaps, or in some other field of medicine.” (Not so surprisingly, in 1977 she
was banned from the East German team as she refused to take PEDs as prescribed
by the team doctors.)
She is right when she says she gave the state quite a lot.
After all, she was discovered by a coach in her hometown of Bitterfeld when she
was only eight years old. When she was 11, she was sent to the sports school
and club in Halle. Probably because of her fantastic performance in Montreal,
Miss Ender received more attention from the Western journalists. It was pointed
out that she is a big woman – broader in the shoulders than most men her age –
and the question of steroid usage was raised.
Professor Kurt Tittel, head of the division of sports
medicine at the German Sports Institute in Leipzig said, “We have developed our
athletes without recourse to anabolics.” Eberhard Schramm, head of swimming
department at Leipzig said that the ideal training regimen for athletes should
include gymnastics, isometrics, games and weightlifting.
“Weights are quite effective” he said, “but only up to about
40 percent of the maximum a swimmer can lift. We want to build endurance and
flexibility, not maximum strength.”
Ski jumpers and skaters also work with weights but they do
it differently. They use heavy weights so as to prepare their muscles for the
bursts of maximum strength required in their particular sport.
Weightlifters, on the other hand, use a variety of
calisthenics and gymnastics-type exercises to increase their flexibility. The
GDR Weightlifting Federation is a strong, independent body with five full-time
administrators and two part-time secretaries as well as two paid national and five
paid regional coaches. There are 7,500 registered lifters in East Germany
compared to just a little over 2,000 for
the United States. Their athletes also participate in far more international
competitions a year than ours. They hose four major international events and
they send teams to about 12 others. Actually, international travel is one of
the big incentives of the East German system. Athletes and government officials
are the only ones who are allowed to travel to capitalistic countries and, it
seems, everyone wants to be among those fortunate few who are allowed outside
the closely-watched borders.
Although there were no defections in Montreal and all the
East German athletes professed a sincere desire to boost the international reputation of their
government, security of the entire sports organization is extremely tight.
Representatives of the FDJ (Free German Youth) and the KEPD (German Communist
Party of Unity) are present at all trainings and competitions to exercise their
supervisory function. The President of the Weightlifting Federation of the GDR
himself is a political appointee and has no experience in weightlifting.
The top lifters are well0-known throughout the country and
are treated as national heroes. Even minor weightlifting events are attended by
huge crowds, whose interest is aroused by detailed reports about the progress
of the sport in the daily press. International weightlifting events are given
direct TV coverage throughout the evening hours for as many days as the
competition lasts.
East German citizens are extremely proud of the
accomplishments of all their athletes. But for Dr. Marder and others in the
West there is doubt about the ideals of amateurism and international
brotherhood that were revived with the Olympic Games in 1896.
“Is this really sport?” wondered Dr. Marder. “You in the
West will have to decide that because someday you won’t be able to compete with
those people fairly if you insist on being amateurs while they put computers,
medicine and a whole society to work turning out champions.”
The choice is ours… and that is appropriate because our system of government is based on choice. Hopefully we will decide to improve our system of training by following the recommendations of the recent Presidential Committee on the Olympics and seek the support of private industry an the American public as well as the Federal Government.
Enjoy your lifting!
“We have developed our athletes without recourse to anabolics.”
ReplyDeleteI wonder if "without recourse" was a mistranslation of an East German idiom meaning, "one continuous course without intervals of no drugs, therefore requiring no re-course".
Because, certainly he couldn't possibly have been lying about those 1970s East German Olympic athletes who suddenly began winning all those medals???
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doping_in_East_Germany#:~:text=The%20government%20of%20the%20German,drugs%2C%20to%20its%20elite%20athletes.
The DDR were trailblazers in sports pharmacology. They were one of the more successful centrally planned economies and had plenty to spend on their doping program.
DeleteAgreed, GREY CAT. Objectively, theirs was enviable.
DeleteIn fifty-plus years of my own drug-free bodybuilding, I've never objected to informed adults choosing to dope. While recognizing the complexities of disclosure and admission, my objection has always been to the understating, dishonesty, and outright lying.
Here's a little more . . . https://www.nytimes.com/1976/12/20/archives/east-german-olympic-system-a-success.html
ReplyDeleteThe book "Faust's Gold" also has more on the doping element and how it was implemented back then. From 1968 to the late 1980s, East Germany (GDR) doped some 9,000 athletes to gain success in international athletic competitions despite being aware of the unfortunate side effects. Quite young athletes, no awareness of what they were being given, but hey . . . records did get made, ta-da! The female swimmers were quite a sight to behold alright and their lives were changed forever . . . As with all things, human nature has a way of showing itself over time in so many ways. Anyhow, that book is very informative, no matter what your views are on doping, ethical coaching, the moral foundations of sport, etc.
ReplyDeleteOn a lighter note, from now on I'm sticking with no more than 40% max when lifting! 'Nuff of this huff-and-puff stuff for me, it's a new day over here and I welcome this incredible lightness of being a lifter!
ReplyDeleteGood Grief, now it's ME that's the pain in the arse in the comments!
ReplyDeleteI'm still getting the hang of the editorial part. Always good to get your two cents here!
DeleteI was constantly hanging myself with it! Hahaha . . . hey, all good and I love the photos with this one.
DeletePBS did a documentary in 2008 - it is on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jR9CUGBVH-Q
ReplyDelete